Playbook Deviation Review
Escalates clauses that fall outside the approved position with the wording, the risk, and a named decision owner.
Pre-review each contract that arrives at legal@acme.inc: compare it with our review checklist, quote any deviations, and send me a summary.
| Clause | Our standard |
|---|---|
| Liability | Capped at 12 months of fees |
| Notice period | 30 days or more |
| Governing law | Our home jurisdiction |
The job, and what good looks like.
What breaks: the playbook lives in a document nobody can search, so reviewers work from memory. The same liability cap gets pushed back twice in one week by two different people, and the business never learns which positions it keeps losing. Deviations also stop at the individual reviewer instead of reaching the person who owns the position, so the next deal starts from the same argument. What the workflow does: it compares each clause as it is marked up against the recorded position, lists the wording we wanted next to the wording we received, and names the risk in one line. Repeated push-back on the same clause is grouped so the pattern is visible. Anything needing a decision is routed to the position owner with the deviation, the precedent, and a suggested fallback. What a person still approves: a lawyer accepts, rejects, or amends the fallback, and only that decision updates the playbook.
When it is handled
- Deviations decided within two business days
- Every exception has a named decision owner
- Repeated push-back tracked by clause
- Playbook updated from approved positions
Works with tools like
- Luminance
- Robin AI
- Ironclad
- Conga
Ready-made automations. Pick the one that fits.
Each one is a plain-language document. Run it as it is, or change the timing, the rules and the tools to match your team.
Contract pre-review
Pre-review each contract that arrives at legal@acme.inc: compare it with our review checklist, quote any deviations, and send me a summary.
Each new contract
Deviation Weekly Review
Every Friday at 4:00pm, pull the contracts with open clause deviations and email one line per contract with the owner and the next step.
Every Friday at 4:00pm
Liability Cap Escalation
When a liability cap lands above the playbook limit, flag the clause, state the exposure, and post it to the review queue.
When a liability cap exceeds the playbook limit
Playbook Deviation Flag
When a clause deviates from the playbook, write the position we wanted next to the position we got, then email the deputy general counsel.
When a clause deviates from the playbook
You stay in charge.
At every step.
It compares and flags. Every legal call stays yours.
- It never signs or advises
It quotes deviations against your playbook. Accepting, signing and advising stay with a lawyer.
- Every flag shows its source
Each deviation quotes the clause it is about, every step is recorded, and a file change can be put back.
- Confidential stays contained
Each automation reaches only the folders you connect for it, and a local model keeps processing on your machine.
Contract pre-review
Approve before it saves the document and sends the email?
Before you download.
- Where does it run?
- On your Mac or Windows computer, in the background. It keeps working after you close its window, and only reaches the folders and apps you connect for each automation.
- How does it connect to our CRM and other tools?
- Through each app's own connection where it offers one, signed in once by you, or by using the app in a browser the way you would. Each automation gets only the connections you give it, and the tools a page names are examples you can swap for your own.
- Does it run when my computer is asleep?
- It keeps your computer awake while a job runs and just before a scheduled one. While the computer is closed or off, nothing runs; when it wakes, it checks the inbox, calendar and other sources it watches for anything that arrived meanwhile.
- How does my team use it?
- Each person who runs automations installs the app. Keep a project in a shared folder, such as Google Drive or a network drive, and teammates can open it and follow every run, while one person owns it and runs it.
- Do I need anyone technical to set it up?
- No. Download the app, add an automation in plain words, and connect only what that job needs. Nothing runs until you switch it on.
Already have tools for this? Here is the difference.
Contract management systems
Storing signed contracts and running approval routes.
Their rules can't read new paper against your playbook or explain a deviation in plain words.
Flowchart automation tools
Moving records between apps.
Clause-level judgment does not fit into branches, and every exception becomes another one to maintain.
AI chat assistants
Summarizing a contract when you paste it in.
Nothing happens until someone asks, and the playbook lives in a chat instead of a document you control.
AUTOMATE.md
Your routine, written in plain words. It runs on its own, follows your rules, handles the exceptions a flowchart can't, and asks you when it matters. The file stays yours, whichever AI model runs it.
Related workflows.
Contract review
Compares incoming clauses against the recorded positions and returns the exceptions as a short list, so a reviewer opens a document with the argument already framed.
1 automation
Contract Intake Triage
Routes every contract request to the right lawyer with the type, value, and risk already read off the document.
3 automations
Redline Negotiation Tracker
Keeps the current version, the open clauses, and who owes the next turn visible on every live negotiation.
3 automations
Start with one job.
Make it your own.
macOS — coming soon- 1
Get the app
It runs on your computer, next to your files.
- 2
Add the automation
Paste the instructions into the app, or save them as a file next to your work.
- 3
Try it, then turn it on
Run it once and check the result. It only runs on its own once you switch it on.